The Village Butcher opened in 2022 and is part of the Quagliata empire. The tucked-away butcher shop is located in a strip mall next to Heinen’s on SOM Center Road near the intersection with Wilson-Mills Road. It is a destination for shoppers in search of imported pantry items, deli meats and cheeses, high-quality steaks and chops, and built-to-order sandwiches. The butcher shop serves as a production site for the restaurants that the Quagliata family owns. They use all Ohio-raised meats like chicken, pork, and beef. The products are all high-quality, and you pay for that quality. Those of us who appreciate that don’t mind paying a little extra. We are happy to support family-run farms and businesses.
 |  |
As you walk in the first thing you see are giant slabs of beef slowly dry aging in a separate room, followed by a large red steel meat scale and a huge counter filled with gorgeous-looking slabs of meat. There is also a small refrigerated counter filled with premade items such as various salads and potato salad, meatloaf and Italian specialties such as lasagna or eggplant parmesan. There is also a modest modern kitchen in the back somewhat out of view where the staff makes the delicious built-to-order sandwiches.
 |  |
The first sandwich I enjoyed was a fish sandwich they advertised for Lent. It looked delectable, and since the butcher shop had been on my radar for a little while I headed straight there to enjoy it. It was one of the best fish sandwiches I have ever enjoyed – tender and flaky with the most delectable tartar sauce. The cod was beer battered and perfectly deep fried. It was also a huge chunk of fish. The brioche bun kind of fell apart toward the end under the large amount of tartar sauce, but I didn’t mind one bit because it did not detract from and only added to the amazing flavor of the sandwich. I can’t wait until Lent so I can enjoy it again.
I bought a slab of lasagna and one of the bacon-wrapped meatloaves that same day to heat and eat later. Both were absolutely delicious. I ate the lasagna over two days, adding a little pasta sauce to moisten it. I also bought another individual-sized meatloaf on my most recent visit as well as some frozen cheesy potatoes. Both paired nicely together for a nice stick-to-your-rubs, meat-and-potatoes meal.
Most recently I tried the special sandwich of the day, a peach and prosciutto sandwich. When I asked how it was one of the employees replied that she liked it and didn’t even like peaches. It features a peach chutney on a sub bun with layers of prosciutto, arugula and slices of cheddar. It was quite tasty – and I do like peaches. I would have never thought to pair peaches with prosciutto, but it works. If you like a salty prosciutto this is one to try next peach season.
I have heard good things about their burgers and the Barbecue Short Rib sandwich. They take Ohio-raised short ribs and sous vide them with rosemary, thyme, salt, garlic and pepper, then cut chilled pieces and fry them a little so they are a little crispy but still soft and juicy on the inside. The meat is then topped with cheddar cheese, some house made sweet and smoky barbecue sauce, black garlic aioli and pickles and onions. It’s on my list for next time.
 |  |
Since it’s a Quagliata business you can stock up on huge cans of tomatoes, frozen homemade Italian pasta, boxed or bagged Italian pasta, and frozen quarts of Italian Sunday sauce and vodka sauce and other soups and finds. The selection is well curated.
Contact info:
The Village Butcher
818 SOM Center Road
Mayfield, OH 44143
(440) 565-7330
Cleveland Rocks, Cleveland Eats 