“Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in!” I thought I was done, but one of my friends contacted me earlier last week and invited me to join her and some of my friends at one last clambake this past Sunday- this time at Gunselman’s. Gunselman’s Tavern in Fairview Park is always a favorite, and their clambake is probably the one clambake I have attended the most. The clambakes sell out quickly and early, so I assumed it wasn’t going to be an option this year. But luckily my friends had bought tickets for several of them. The clambakes are dine-in only and require the purchase of a clambake to enter the establishment. This year the weather was allowing outdoor seating as well as indoor. The Browns game made it almost impossible to hear each other this year.
I usually get the steak bake at Gunselman’s, but my friends had bought chicken bakes because the steak bakes were sold out when they got their tickets. They start serving clam broth and clam chowder at 1 PM and serve the clambakes at 2 PM. I got there at 12:45 and joined my friend inside. I debated if I wanted a beer or a glass of wine, but ended up ordering a cocktail that intrigued me – a Chocolate Peanut Butter Old Fashioned, which features Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey, orange bitters, chocolate bitters and simple syrup. I really loved it and might have to buy some peanut butter whiskey and chocolate bitters so I can make them at home. I would probably add a splash of half and half, but even without it was a delightfully inventive cocktail. I’m also intrigued by the Autumn Aperol Spritz that features sparkling wine, Aperol and apple cider.
We were given a cup of steaming broth as we sat, and once the others in our party arrived we were served a bowl of Irish Kevin’s delicious New England clam chowder. The chowder had chunks of redskin potatoes and was nicely seasoned with a lot of thyme, which gave it a unique and delicious flavor.
The clams were great – tender and not gritty. According to the Gunselman’s website, “the clams are sourced from Joe at Lobster Brothers in Westlake, who has a source in Narragansett Bay, RI, which is home to the finest clams in this part of the world.” The server happily got me a side of barbecue sauce for my roast chicken, and I happily enjoyed the clams, corn, the leg portion of my half chicken, the roll, and a couple bites of the redskin and sweet potatoes. I got a box for the breast portion of my chicken and the redskin and sweet potatoes.
Several of us also ordered cheesecake – mostly to go. One of the servers proudly told us she had made blueberry and cherry cheesecake. When I ordered I told the server that I didn’t care which one she brought and to just bring me a slice of the one they had more of left. She brought me a slice of the blueberry cheesecake, and it was really nice (I had a bite of mine from the carryout box).
We made sure to ask whether the tickets included a gratuity and it did not. I hope the other diners were aware of this and tipped accordingly. I added the price of my preordered ticket to my drink and cheesecake tab and tipped our server for the full price. It would be nice if they would make it clear to everyone at some point, because I hope the servers didn’t walk out of the set dining hours with less than they would normally make – especially since it cut into the Browns “customers” (they didn’t serve brunch today in preparation and the kitchen opened at 3 PM as we were leaving).
So that was my final clambake of the 2024 Clambake Season, and I’m glad it was a good one. I love this quirky Cleveland tradition.
Contact info:
Gunselman’s Tavern
21490 Lorain Road
Fairview Park, OH 44126
(440) 331-5719
Cleveland Rocks, Cleveland Eats 