Smokehouse 91 opened in March 2025 and is located next to The Village Butcher on SOM Center Road near the intersection with Wilson Mills in the small strip mall next to Heinen’s. Smokehouse 91 and Village Butcher actually share a fairly large kitchen now, which means the menu at Village Butcher is also larger. It features “Texas barbeque” and is the next iteration of Smokin’ Q’s, which closed in January 2024. Smokehouse 91 is operated by Smokin’ Q’s owners Carl Quagliata and Zach Ladner. Smokehouse 91 is a fast-casual concept with several tables if you want to eat in-house.
 |  |
They focus on the brisket, although other meats are also available. The meat is smoked low and slow, and you can add barbeque sauces, which are made in house. The sauces include sweet chili, hot & spicy, sweet & tangy mustard, Carolina vinegar, Alabama white, sweet & smokey and Texas-style. I liked the mustard and sweet & smokey the best because those are my preferences. The chopped brisket sandwich was pricy at $18, but it contains a ton of delicious brisket and it is high quality. I love that it is lean, because I’m not a huge fan of fatty meat. I got it topped with pickles and coleslaw, which I highly recommend if you enjoy coleslaw on barbecue. The pickles and coleslaw cut through the richness of the brisket and are a great pairing.
 |  |
 |  |
I usually don’t enjoy barbeque, because the sides are usually disappointing because they are an after-thought. Not here. Their sides include barbeque classics like mac n cheese, collard greens with pork, coleslaw, seasonal potatoes and more. The mac n cheese can be topped with a garlic crumb mix and is incredibly cheesy (and garlicky with the crumb topping). In fact, I find it to be too cheesy and never thought I’d say that. When I reheated it it was very dense and hard to spoon from the container to the bowl. The cornbread is quite nice and is served with a pot of honey butter. I like cornbread and have made my own for 30 years. This one is right up there. It was moist and had small bits of corn in it. I wasn’t a huge fan of the collard greens, but I rarely find collard greens in a restaurant that I enjoy. I think I’ve only found one or two that I enjoy, but others might find it enjoyable. I like the addition of pork. I usually use a ham hock when I make my favorite recipe at home.
 |  |
The standout for me was the banana pudding. I don’t think I’ve ever had a more delicious banana pudding – and my gold standard was Walter Hyde’s at Fat Casual. I savored every last bite over the two days I ate it. It is creamy and has the perfect amount of sliced bananas and whipped cream to pudding ratio.
Smokehouse 91 is open from 11:30 a.m. to 7 p.m., Tuesday through Saturday. Unless they run out of meat earlier. Be sure to check it out if you are in the area. I’m only a 20 minute drive, which is enough for the food to not cool down too much to enjoy at home. I need to try the smoked turkey next.
Contact info:
Smokehouse 91
822 Som Center Road
Mayfield, OH 44143
(440) 565-7160
Cleveland Rocks, Cleveland Eats 